Tailored Coverage, Trusted Protection

Coverage No Matter Where You Are in Life

We offer affordable, personalized coverage to individuals and businesses in West Virginia, Ohio, and Kentucky.

"Your needs — Our purpose"

COMMITTED TO YOU

At Starkey Insurance Group, we take pride in being your local, independent insurance agency. With access to over 25+ trusted carriers, we don’t believe in one-size-fits-all coverage — we take the time to understand your unique needs and find the best policy to match.

Whether it’s home, auto, business, life, or renters insurance, we’re here to shop around for you and make sure you’re getting the right protection at the right price — not just today, but every year at renewal too.

WHY CHOOSE US

Community First, Always.

Established Expertise (Since 2022)

Built on integrity and personalized service, we combine fresh energy with years of industry experience to deliver reliable insurance solutions tailored to your needs.

Independent & Informed

As an independent agency, we partner with multiple top-rated carriers to give you the best options available. More importantly, we don’t just set your policy and forget it—we actively monitor it.
If we notice an increase in your premium or when your policy reaches renewal, we automatically re-shop your coverage to make sure you’re still getting the best value—so you don’t have to worry or keep track of it yourself.

Local Service with a Personal Touch

We’re proud to serve our community with genuine, personalized attention. With us, you’re not just a policy number—you’re part of the Starkey Insurance Group family.

People

Over

Policies

Because protecting you should feel simple, proactive, and stress-free.

TESTIMONIALS

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

"Thank you, Ethan Starkey for all of your help with switching insurance! And, lowering my monthly rate!!!"

Andrea Tracker

Lead Teacher

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

"Insurance went up from $266 to $324 when I got my new car. Well, I just got done shopping with Starkey Insurance Group & they were able to get me down to $255 a month which is cheaper than what we have had in over a year! Same great coverage, just for less $! Thank you Ethan Starkey for all of your help!"